20 Absent Stories: Representation, Identity, and Belonging in Cultural Institutions
Carolina Arellanos
Absent Stories: Representation, Identity, and Belonging in Cultural Institutions

Discussion Questions
- In what ways do the Lubbock Gallery’s current displays represent or omit the community’s diverse histories, and what narratives are being centered through these choices?
- How might the visitor’s experience influence her perception of the Museum and of Texas Tech University as a public institution?
- How does Strayhorn’s conceptual framework help explain the significance of this interaction?
- What practical steps can institutions take to ensure more inclusive representation in their exhibits, events, and public communications?
Introduction
During a quiet afternoon walkthrough of the Lubbock Gallery at the Museum of Texas Tech University, I watched a visitor move slowly along the mural-lined walls. She paused often–leaning in, studying, stepping back. The gallery is designed to guide viewers through Lubbock’s early history: featuring vast agricultural landscapes, cotton fields stretching toward the horizon, a bustling downtown in the 1930s, ranchers, farmers, and the familiar imagery of West Texas Identity. Warm spotlights illuminate each panel, casting long shadows that make scenes feel frozen in time.
But for the visitor, something essential was missing.
She turned to my supervisor and asked, quietly but deliberately, “Excuse me, sir, where are all the Black people?”
Her question was not confrontational; it was observational. Yet it landed with unmistakable force. In a room meant to represent the history of this West Texas rural city, her words made visible what the murals had rendered invisible. Entire communities—Black, Hispanic, Indigenous, and Asian—were absent, erased through omission rather than intention.
My supervisor provided a brief explanation of the gallery’s original curatorial vision, its historical scope, and the commissioning timeline. The visitor nodded politely, but her expression revealed something deeper: a moment of dislocation, of realizing that the space she was standing in did not see her or her history. After she walked away, her question lingered in the air, reshaping how we saw the walls around us.
Cultural Spaces as Storytellers
That moment illuminated a truth I had long understood: cultural spaces are powerful storytellers. Museums and galleries do more than display objects–they construct narratives. They teach the public who “we” are, what we value, and whose histories matter.
Within higher education, university museums serve as public classrooms and sites for intercultural communication. They are not neutral. They affirm or deny belonging through imagery, narrative, and visibility. As Hall (1997) reminds us, representation is never simply descriptive—it is formative.
In this gallery, the absence of Black representation was itself a communicative act. The murals did not just omit people—they suggested that some groups were peripheral to the story of West Texas. For marginalized communities, such absences echo a long history of being rendered invisible.
As I continued walking through the space, I began to see the murals differently—not as static artistic works, but as institutional narratives. What stories were centered? Whose stories were missing? And what did these choices communicate to our diverse student body and community?
Belonging, Visibility, and Institutional Identity
Strayhorn’s (2019) framework argues that belonging is not simply being in a space—it is feeling recognized within it. Cultural institutions shape that recognition. When visitors search for themselves and find nothing, the message is clear: this story is not about you.
As a university museum, the Lubbock Gallery is part of Texas Tech University’s public identity. It communicates who the institution acknowledges and celebrates. For many visitors, such narratives can either invite them in or mark them as outsiders.
This encounter prompted deeper reflection about the responsibilities of cultural institutions. It underscored how representation—or the lack of it—influences belonging and trust. Cultural spaces are not passive; they actively shape community connection.
Reframing the Narrative
In the days after the encounter, our staff revisited the gallery’s interpretive goals. We discussed the murals’ historical limitations and whose voices had shaped the original commission. We considered how future renovations might more accurately reflect the diverse communities that have shaped Lubbock and Texas Tech University.
The moment served as an institutional mirror, prompting questions that extend beyond a single gallery:
• How do we responsibly steward cultural spaces?
• How do we address omissions without erasing artistic intent?
• How do we ensure visitors from all backgrounds can see themselves reflected?
These questions are not simple—but they are necessary.
The visitor’s question revealed how omissions in institutional storytelling are felt in real time. Museums, especially in higher education, carry responsibilities beyond preservation; they must engage in equitable representation and intentional narrative building.
Cultural spaces do not merely hold stories; they create them. And when we choose the stories we tell, we choose which communities we invite into belonging.
Recommended Readings
Hall, S. (1997). Representation: Cultural representations and signifying practices. Sage.
Strayhorn, T. L. (2019). Consequences of sense of belonging. In College students’ sense of belonging: A key to educational success for all students (2nd ed.). Routledge.